The Baofeng UV-17 and UV-5RM are both popular dual-band handheld transceivers, each offering distinct features tailored to different user preferences. Below is a comparative overview to assist in determining which model aligns better with your needs.
Design and Display
UV-17: Features a modern design with a larger, more vibrant display, enhancing readability and user experience.
UV-5RM: Maintains the classic Baofeng aesthetic with a standard display, which may be less vivid compared to the UV-17.
Frequency Range and Bands
UV-17: Covers the standard VHF (136-174 MHz) and UHF (400-520 MHz) frequencies. Some users have reported that their units can transmit on the 1.25-meter band (220-225 MHz) at 2.5 watts, though this may vary by device.
UV-5RM: Operates primarily on VHF and UHF bands. Users have noted the ability to receive airband frequencies; however, audio quality in AM airband mode is suboptimal, with me experiencing distortion on strong signals, to the point that listening to the airband is a painful experience.
Transmit Power
UV-17: Offers high transmit power, with some reports indicating up to 5 watts on certain bands.
UV-5RM: Marketed as delivering up to 5 watts of transmit power, with selectable low, medium, and high power.
Additional Features
UV-17: Equipped with dual alarm functions, including a local alarm through the speaker and a broadcast alarm with siren/coded signals over the air.
UV-5RM: Includes standard features typical of Baofeng radios but lacks advanced functionalities like GPS.
User Feedback
UV-17: Generally receives positive feedback for its audio quality and feature set. Users appreciate its performance across various bands and the enhanced display.
UV-5RM: While appreciated for its reliability, some users have reported issues with audio quality, especially when receiving strong signals in AM airband mode.
Conclusion
If you prioritize a modern interface, enhanced display, and additional features like dual alarms, the UV-17 may be the preferable choice. Conversely, if you value a classic design with standard functionalities and are primarily operating within VHF and UHF bands, the UV-5RM remains a solid option.
No comments:
Post a Comment