I've been eyeing off the Uniden USDS100 for several years now. As someone who has been involved in the radio scanning hobby for almost 30 years, I'm always interested in seeing what new developments are happening in the scanner world.
However, one question has always held me back: are the improvements offered by the USDS100 really worth the extra money over my existing UBCD436PT? With around $150 separating the two models, it isn't an insignificant upgrade.
Recently, I finally had the opportunity to answer that question for myself. I was able to borrow a Uniden USDS100 for a week while its owner was working interstate. I've known the owner for more than 15 years and had recently helped them program the radio after they purchased the DMR and NXDN upgrade keys. Having the radio available for an extended period gave me a chance to put it through its paces and compare it directly with my Uniden UBCD436PT.
A little bit of history
Before getting into the review, it's probably worth providing a little background about my experience with radio scanners.
I've been involved in the hobby for almost 30 years and have always enjoyed exploring new technology and pushing scanners beyond their intended out-of-the-box use.
Back in the early 2000s, I was one of the first people to successfully program a Uniden UBC245XLT to trunk track Tasmania's EDACS network. In the mid-2000s, I also imported one of the first Uniden BCD396T scanners from the United States into Australia.
I've always enjoyed experimenting with new scanners, programming systems and exploring what these radios can do. So, when the opportunity came along to spend a week with the USDS100, I was genuinely interested to see how it compared with the UBCD436PT.
Programming and menus
One of the first things I noticed was just how familiar everything felt. The programming, menus and general operation are very similar to the UBCD436PT. Having spent plenty of time using the UBCD436PT, I felt right at home with the USDS100.
There wasn't a significant learning curve, and I was able to get straight into using the radio rather than spending hours working out where everything was. For existing Uniden users, this is a definite positive. You're getting a different receiver platform and a more modern display, without having to learn an entirely new operating system.
Physical design and handling
The USDS100 is physically a little shorter than the UBCD436PT, but it is noticeably thicker. A significant reason for this is the battery pack. The USDS100 uses an SDR-based receiver, which has higher power requirements than the traditional receiver design in the UBCD436PT. This requires a different battery arrangement.
In the hand, I actually quite liked the feel of the USDS100. It feels solid, and the overall shape is comfortable to hold.
The colour display is another obvious improvement. It provides considerably more visual information and makes the radio feel like a much more modern piece of equipment. However, I wasn't particularly impressed with the feel of the keypad. It just didn't feel as nice to use as I would have liked.
Receiver performance
This was probably the area I was most interested in testing. My normal scanning activities involve monitoring and searching the VHF and UHF bands, identifying users, confirming frequencies and documenting activity.
I spend quite a bit of time using Discovery Mode and recording activity, rather than simply programming a collection of known frequencies and leaving the scanner running.
In general scanning and searching, I found the USDS100's performance to be comparable to the UBCD436PT.
There were a couple of differences worth mentioning.
Birdies: I noticed fewer birdies on the USDS100 compared with the 436PT. This was a welcome improvement, particularly when searching across different sections of the bands.
DMR and NXDN: I also found the USDS100's decoding performance to be slightly better. In particular, I noticed fewer dropouts when monitoring digital transmissions.
These aren't necessarily night-and-day differences, but they are noticeable improvements. For someone who spends a lot of time searching and identifying signals, even relatively small improvements in receiver performance can make a difference.
Tasmania's P25 network – TASGRN
One area where I was limited in my testing was the Tasmanian Government Radio Network (TASGRN).
As many local scanner enthusiasts will know, the number of unencrypted users on the TASGRN is quite limited. This makes it difficult to conduct extensive testing of P25 reception and decoding. The few users I was able to hear in the clear sounded much the same on both the USDS100 and UBCD436PT.
There is also an important consideration when comparing the USDS100 with other scanners: Linear Simulcast Modulation (LSM). One of the major advantages of the SDS series is its ability to handle difficult simulcast environments, where traditional scanner receivers can struggle with distortion and missed transmissions. We don't have LSM to contend with here in Tasmania, so that particular advantage isn't something I can really benefit from.
This is an important point when considering an upgrade. A feature can be extremely valuable, but only if you have a practical need for it.
For someone living in an area with a challenging simulcast P25 network, the USDS100 could be a very different proposition.
Things I loved
There were several things about the USDS100 that I really enjoyed.
The colour display
This is probably the most immediately noticeable improvement. The display is excellent, providing plenty of information and making the radio feel like a modern scanner.
The feel in the hand
Despite being thicker than the 436PT, I found the SDS100 comfortable to hold. It feels like a well-built piece of equipment.
Receiver performance
Overall, RF performance was good. The reduction in birdies and slightly improved DMR and NXDN decoding were welcome improvements.
Things I didn't love
It wasn't all positive, though. There were a few things that I found disappointing.
The proprietary battery pack
This is probably my biggest complaint. I understand why Uniden has gone down this route. The SDR receiver has higher power requirements, and the battery arrangement reflects that. However, one of the things I really appreciate about the UBCD436PT is its ability to use standard AA batteries. I can carry spare batteries with me, replace them when needed or simply purchase another set from a local shop if I'm out and about.
With the SDS100, you're much more dependent on the proprietary battery pack and having access to charging facilities. For my style of portable monitoring, this is a genuine disadvantage.
Audio quality
I wasn't particularly impressed with the audio. For a scanner with an Australian retail price approaching $1,000, I expected a little more in this department. The audio wasn't terrible, but it certainly wasn't something that stood out as a positive.
Keypad feel
As mentioned earlier, I wasn't particularly fond of the keypad. This is a relatively minor complaint, but when you're spending extended periods operating a radio, these little things matter.
Is it worth the upgrade?
This is really the question I've been trying to answer for several years.
The USDS100 is undoubtedly a nice radio. It represents just how far radio scanner technology has progressed, and there are some genuine improvements over the UBCD436PT. However, the value of those improvements depends heavily on how you use your scanner and what radio systems you need to monitor.
If I lived somewhere with challenging LSM simulcast systems, the USDS100 would be a much more attractive proposition. Its ability to handle those environments could make the difference between successfully monitoring a system and struggling with missed transmissions.
Likewise, if I wanted a scanner primarily for use at home, sitting on a charger and monitoring programmed systems, the battery limitations would be much less of an issue.
But that's not necessarily how I use my scanners. A lot of my enjoyment comes from portable monitoring, searching the bands, exploring new frequencies, identifying users and documenting what I hear. For that type of activity, the UBCD436PT continues to be an extremely capable radio.
I also have to consider the practical risks of carrying an expensive piece of equipment around. There's the possibility of accidental damage, but also the risk of theft. When you're carrying a scanner worth close to $1,000, you do think a little differently about where you take it and how you use it.
Overall
The Uniden USDS100 is an excellent scanner, but it isn't necessarily the right upgrade for everyone.
I thoroughly enjoyed having the opportunity to use one for a week. It gave me a chance to move beyond specifications, online reviews and other people's opinions and actually compare it against the radio I use every day.
The colour display is excellent, the receiver performance is good, and the improvements in DMR and NXDN decoding are welcome.
However, for my particular requirements, the UBCD436PT still represents better value.
The ability to use standard AA batteries is particularly important to me, especially given how much of my scanning involves portable use and searching the bands.
The USDS100 is currently Uniden's top-of-the-line handheld scanner in Australia, and it certainly deserves that position. But being the top-of-the-line model doesn't automatically make it the best choice for every scanner enthusiast.
For now, I'll be sticking with my UBCD436PT.
That doesn't mean I've lost interest in the USDS100. Quite the opposite. It's a very interesting piece of equipment, and I'm glad I finally had the opportunity to spend some time with one.
But after nearly 30 years in the scanning hobby, I've learned that the newest and most expensive radio isn't always the one that best suits the way you enjoy the hobby.
